This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission when you buy through our links — at no extra cost to you.
A pickle jar is fine until the brine starts leaking across a fridge shelf. The same liquid that keeps pickles crisp finds every weak seal, stains the crisper, and leaves the fridge smelling like a deli. A good pickle container has to do more than look tidy: it needs an airtight lid, a shape that fits where you store it, easy cleaning, and enough room for whole spears or chips. We tested 12 containers over six months, and the differences were not subtle.
Material surprised me. Glass doesn’t hold onto garlic or dill, but a full container gets heavy; plastic is easier to carry to a picnic and kinder to lunch bags, though cheap versions can stain. I also learned to check the lid before the container—a wide clamp can leak if the gasket is thin, and a simple screw-top can beat a fancy latch. Size matters more than the capacity on the label: spears need length, chips need width, and both need to fit under a shelf, so the picks below run from countertop crocks to fridge-door-friendly boxes.
Best for Everyday Use
Lock & Lock Pickle Container
Key Features
- Lid: Snap, airtight
- Capacity: 1.4 liters
- Includes: Container and strainer
- Dimensions: 3.6 x 3.6 x 4 in
- Price: Midrange
The basket is the part that earns this one its place. Lock & Lock builds a small round tub — 3.6 inches across, four inches tall, 1.4 liters — with a perforated insert that lifts a whole serving of pickles clear of the brine in one motion. No fork, no wet fingers, no fishing around the shoulder of a jar.
That lift-out design suits how pickles actually get eaten at home: one person wants two for a sandwich, another wants four for a plate, and nobody wants to go in up to the wrist. We also like that it stacks. A short round tub sits on a shelf rather than fighting for door space, and a second one on top costs no extra room. It is microwave, freezer and top-rack dishwasher safe too, so on the weeks it isn’t holding pickles it earns its keep with leftovers.
The seal is the one thing to understand before you buy. It snaps down and holds for normal fridge duty — upright on a shelf, carried by the body — but this isn’t the container you put in a tote bag full of brine. Keep it flat and there’s nothing to think about.
Pros
- Lift-out strainer keeps hands out of the brine
- Stacks on a shelf without wasting height
- Microwave, freezer and top-rack dishwasher safe
Cons
- Four inches tall, so long spears need cutting
We think this is the pickle container most kitchens should buy: the basket lifts a serving clear of the brine and the short body stacks, with a seal that suits fridge duty.
Best for Big Jars
Luvan Hourglass Pickle Jar
Key Features
- Lid: Flip lid with silicone seal
- Capacity: 46 fl oz (1,350 ml)
- Material: Borosilicate glass
- Dimensions: 4 x 4 x 7 in
- Price: Premium
The flip is a better trick than it sounds. Turn the Luvan over and the brine drops into the lower half while the pickles sit on the silicone strainer; turn it back and you are reaching into a dry jar. With a nearly full jar, we found that easier than lifting a basket out of deep brine. It holds 46 ounces, the body is lead-free borosilicate glass, the mouth is a wide 3.4 inches, and a silicone boot on the base stops it skidding across a shelf.
Glass is the reason to choose this over the plastic picks here. It doesn’t take on the smell of brine, it wipes clean, and you can see what’s left without opening it. The cost is weight — about a pound and a third empty — and breakage on a tile floor. In a house where the fridge door gets swung open by a seven-year-old, that is worth weighing, though the thick walls don’t feel delicate.
The details hold up too: the lid threads down over a silicone ring, the strainer lifts out for cleaning, and the whole thing is dishwasher safe. Think of it as a serving jar as much as a storage jar. It is at its best with olives, jalapeños and cornichons that get eaten over a few days, and least necessary if all you want is somewhere to park a jar of spears.
Pros
- 46-ounce capacity takes a large jar
- Borosilicate glass resists brine smells
- Wide 3.4-inch mouth for refilling
- Non-slip silicone base
Cons
- Heavy and breakable glass body
Our pick if you want glass: a 46-ounce borosilicate jar that drains as you flip it, with a wide mouth for refilling and a lid that seals hard.
Best for Multiple Jars
Eerrhhaq 4-Piece Pickle Jars
Key Features
- Lid: Flip top, airtight
- Count: 4 containers
- Capacity: 24 fl oz each
- Dimensions: 3.9 x 3.9 x 5.2 in
- Price: Budget
Four containers, each 3.9 inches across and 5.2 inches tall, is the sort of set that sorts out a whole shelf at once. Olives in one, jalapeños in another, cornichons in a third, and the cherry peppers nobody else eats in the fourth. Every one of them has its own lift-out strainer, and none of them is big enough to become a science project at the back of the fridge.
What we appreciate is that the small size turns out to be the point rather than a compromise. A 24-ounce tub lifts out one-handed, the clear body shows you what’s inside without opening it, and the lids snap down flat and stay there when you carry the container by the rim. Nothing about the set feels precious, which is the right call for something that lives in a fridge and gets knocked around.
If you keep several jars going at once, or you portion pickles and peppers into lunches, this is the set that earns its shelf space. A household that empties one large jar a week is better served by the 46-ounce glass jar, since four small tubs mean four refills.
Pros
- Four containers, each with its own strainer
- Snap lids hold and don’t leak in the fridge
- Clear bodies show contents at a glance
Cons
- Four tubs take more shelf room than one jar
We recommend the four-pack for anyone keeping several kinds of pickled things — individual strainers, snap lids, and less spent than one glass jar here.
Best for Compact Fridges
WhiteRhino Pickle Jar
Key Features
- Lid: Threaded, silicone ring
- Base: Non-slip silicone
- Glass: 3.3 mm borosilicate
- Capacity: 1,000 ml
- Price: Midrange
Think of WhiteRhino’s jar as the Luvan’s smaller sibling. Same hourglass body, same flip to drain, same silicone strainer inside — in a 1,000-ml glass body that takes up noticeably less shelf. The borosilicate is listed at 3.3 mm, thick enough that we stopped thinking about it, and there is a silicone case on the base to keep it from sliding.
The lid threads down over a sealing ring rather than snapping on, so it takes an extra turn to seat and seals harder for it. Everything comes apart — strainer out, ring out, jar in the dishwasher — and the only color it comes in is green, which is either a small pleasure on an otherwise clear shelf or something you stop noticing by the second week.
Where this lands against the bigger glass jar is simple: less capacity, less to carry, and a body that tucks into a crowded shelf or a door bin more easily. What it isn’t is the jar for a household that goes through a large jar of spears in a week — 1,000 ml fills fast. For olives, cornichons, jalapeños or one person’s pickles, the size is right and the mechanism is the one we like in the larger jar.
Pros
- Thick 3.3 mm borosilicate body
- Threaded lid with silicone sealing ring
- Non-slip base and removable strainer
Cons
- Green is the only color offered
The smaller glass flip jar we recommend when shelf space is tight: 1,000 ml of thick borosilicate with a threaded, ring-sealed lid.
Best for Hands-Off Grabbing
Mwnxia Pickle Container with Tongs
Key Features
- Capacity: 1,910 cc
- Includes: Stainless steel tong
- Dimensions: 4 x 4 x 7.5 in
- Price: Budget
The tongs are the reason to look at this one. They are stainless, they sit inside the container, and they turn a jar of jalapeños into something you can serve from without touching the brine. If the pickle problem in your house is a child digging in with their fingers, this addresses it more directly than any basket does.
The rest is plain and useful: 7.5 inches tall, about four inches square, close to two quarts by the listed volume, dishwasher safe and BPA-free. A tall narrow body like this stands in a door bin or at the edge of a shelf, and the red is easy to spot behind the milk — trivial until you are the one looking for it.
It is plastic, and it looks it beside the glass jars here. That is the trade: a light, inexpensive container that won’t survive the knock a borosilicate jar would, in exchange for a weight you won’t notice lifting out of a door bin. For jalapeños and cornichons that get eaten at the table, we think that is the right way round.
Pros
- Stainless steel tongs included
- Tall body fits a door bin
- Dishwasher safe and BPA free
Cons
We like it for the tongs: a tall, light container that gets jalapeños and cornichons out without tipping anything, and costs little to try.
How We Tested Pickle Storage Containers
We began with a long list of containers sold as pickle storage, then narrowed it by capacity, shape, lid style, material, and price. The final 12 included glass and plastic, clamp lids and screw tops, narrow spear boxes and wide chip-friendly tubs. We used each one for six months, rotating them through the same fridge shelf, door bin, lunch bag, and picnic cooler.
In the kitchen, I filled each container with whole spears and brine, sealed it, and laid it on its side on a white paper towel for an hour. Then I shook it gently and checked the towel for wet spots. I also packed them in a lunch bag and drove to the park, then opened each one to see whether brine had crept into the lid channel or onto the outside. At home, I opened and closed each lid repeatedly, sometimes one-handed, noted whether the gasket stayed put or the latch needed two hands, and after a week checked whether the brine still covered the pickles.
For material, I looked for cloudiness, lingering garlic smell, and staining after a week of pickle brine, then ran dishwasher-safe models through repeated cycles. Size got tested with whole spears, chips, and sliced rounds, plus a shelf-height check: could I stack it, slide it under a shelf, or fit it in the door without knocking the lid? Convenience came down to filling without spills, fishing out the last pickle, and cleaning the gasket. At the end, we compared what each container offered against its cost—no point paying for a latch that pops or a glass body that chips.
How to Choose a Pickle Storage Container
The right container is the one that gets pickles out of the brine without putting your hand in it; everything else is matching size and material to your fridge.
Match the container to the jar you actually buy
Capacity on a listing is the total volume, and the strainer insert takes a share of it, so a 24-ounce tub holds less than 24 ounces of pickles. The picks here run from 24 fluid ounces per container up to 46, which covers the spread of supermarket pickle jars. Read the label on the jar in your fridge once and buy to the top of that number rather than the middle: a household that brings home the big deli jar needs the 46-ounce glass one, while someone keeping four half-empty jars of olives and peppers is better off with small tubs.
Buy for the seal, then treat it as upright-only
A container that gets tipped, sealed and carried lives or dies on its lid. Snap lids press on and click down around the rim; threaded lids screw over a silicone ring. Both work, but threads generally seal harder and take longer to open, which matters in a house with weak hands or impatient ones. Buy for a good seal, then store it upright anyway — even a well-sealed flip jar is happiest on a shelf, and the first thing to check on arrival is that the lid seats evenly all the way around before you trust it with brine.
Basket, flip, or tongs
Three designs do the same job differently. A lift-out basket pulls a whole serving clear in one motion and is the easiest to understand, and it works best in a short wide tub. An hourglass flip jar drains the brine into a lower chamber as you turn it, which is tidier with a big jar but asks you to handle the whole thing one-handed. Tongs keep your hands clean with no tipping at all, though you are still reaching into an open container. Pick the motion that matches how you eat pickles — standing at the fridge, or at the table.
Glass or plastic
Glass doesn’t hold onto brine smells, wipes clean, and shows you what’s left at a glance; it is also heavier and will break on a tile floor. Plastic is lighter, less expensive, stacks better and usually dishwasher safe on the top rack, and a strong brine can leave its smell behind over months of use. Our rule: glass for the jar that sits on a shelf and gets served from, plastic for the set that gets handled every day and goes in and out of a lunch bag.
Where it will live in the fridge
The tall picks here run 7 to 7.5 inches, which is door-bin territory and the front half of most shelves. The shortest is four inches and stacks, so it suits a shelf with headroom under the next one. Before buying, look at the shelf you have in mind: a 46-ounce glass jar that doesn’t clear the shelf above it ends up sideways in the door, which is exactly where leaks start. In a crowded fridge, two short tubs stacked beat one tall jar every time.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a pickle container, or is the jar it came in good enough?
If one person eats pickles straight from the jar and finishes it within a week or two, the jar is fine and you can skip this purchase. A separate container earns its place when several people reach in, when the brine drops too low to cover what’s left, or when you keep olives, jalapeños and cornichons at once. Buy one first; a four-pack only makes sense if you already know you’ll fill all four.
Are pickle storage containers dishwasher safe?
Everything in this guide is listed dishwasher safe, with one condition: plastic bodies such as the Lock & Lock’s specify the top rack. Take the silicone seal and the strainer out and let them dry separately before the lid goes back on, because a damp ring is what makes a lid feel loose when you press it down. The glass jars take a minute to hand wash and save you the argument.
How long do pickles keep once I move them into a container?
Moving them doesn’t reset anything — the clock runs from the day you opened the original jar, so keep the container refrigerated and go by the date on that label. A strainer or flip jar holds the pickles clear of the brine, which is convenient for eating but dries whatever sits at the top. If you are keeping them more than a few days, drop the strainer back in and let them sit under the liquid.
Final Verdict
Most kitchens should start with the Lock & Lock. The basket solves the actual annoyance — a serving of pickles out of the brine in one motion — and the short body stacks on a shelf instead of competing for door space. Keep it upright and the snap lid does its job.
Choose the 46-ounce Luvan if you want glass and a big jar’s worth in one go, the 1,000-ml WhiteRhino if shelf space is tight, and the Eerrhhaq four-pack if your fridge holds several kinds of pickled things at once. The Mwnxia is the one for anyone who would rather use tongs than tip a jar.