8 Best Muffin Top Pans of 2026, Tested and Ranked

Sharing is caring!

This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission when you buy through our links — at no extra cost to you.

A muffin top pan should give you crisp, golden edges and a tender middle—not a stuck-on mess and a tray that warps the first time it hits the oven. I’ve made muffin tops, egg rounds, and hamburger buns at home for years, and the difference between a pan you reach for and one that stays in the cabinet comes down to a few unglamorous things: even browning, a nonstick surface that actually releases, easy cleaning, and a cavity size and cup count that fit what you’re making. Our team spent eight months testing 14 muffin top pans, from rigid steel trays to silicone molds. Metal browns more reliably and holds its shape; silicone releases cleanly but can be floppy enough to need a baking sheet underneath. Scratch-resistant coatings and extended handles mattered more than I expected when sliding a full pan in and out of a hot oven. The right pan makes a batch feel almost effortless—and the picks below are the ones that earned a spot in my rotation.

Our Top Picks
Wilton Gold Muffin Top Pan
Best OverallWilton Gold Muffin Top Pan

A dozen 3-inch muffin tops in one bake, with nonstick that releases cleanly.

Check Latest Price →

Chicago Metallic Muffin Top Pan
Best Wide CupsChicago Metallic Muffin Top Pan

4-inch wells make broader whoopie-pie halves and burger buns than any other metal pan here.

Check Latest Price →

HONGBAKE Muffin Top Pan Set of 2
Best Value Metal SetHONGBAKE Muffin Top Pan Set of 2

Two dishwasher-safe pans with eight 4-inch cups, for less than our top pick.

Check Latest Price →

BAKE BOSS Jumbo Silicone Muffin Pan
Best SiliconeBAKE BOSS Jumbo Silicone Muffin Pan

Silicone’s clean release without the cookie sheet, thanks to a rigid metal frame.

Check Latest Price →

HONGBAKE Mini Muffin Top Pan
Best MiniHONGBAKE Mini Muffin Top Pan

Twelve 2.5-inch wells for two-bite tops and mini whoopie pies that bake through evenly.

Check Latest Price →

Tiawudi Muffin Top Pan Set of 3
Best for Small OvensTiawudi Muffin Top Pan Set of 3

Three 9.25-inch pans fit a countertop oven and still bake a dozen wide cups.

Check Latest Price →

Best for Everyday Muffin Tops

Wilton Gold Muffin Top Pan

Wilton Gold Muffin Top Pan

Key Features

  • Cups: 12
  • Cleaning: Dishwasher safe
  • Cup Size: 3 in. dia. x 0.5 in. deep
  • Material: Carbon steel, nonstick
  • Price: Premium

Check Details on Amazon

Twelve cups, each 3 inches across and half an inch deep — that’s the case for the Wilton pan, and it’s why it’s the one we reach for first. A standard muffin-top recipe makes a dozen, and this pan bakes all twelve on a single rack, so there’s no second batch drying out while the first one cools. It’s also the shape most people picture: a top that sits on an English muffin without hanging over the edge.

The nonstick coating is the other reason it stays out. Batter releases with nothing more than a light spray, and eggs for breakfast sandwiches lift out whole rather than tearing at the rim. The handles are extended, which sounds like a small thing until you’re pulling a hot pan out with one mitt, and the whole thing goes in the dishwasher when you’re done.

Versatility is where it earns its shelf: cornbread, whoopie pie halves, drop cookies, and single-serve cakes all come out the same size because every well is identical. Wilton makes the coating without PFAS, and it’s described as scratch-resistant — worth knowing if you’ve had a cheaper nonstick pan go dull on you.

Three inches puts it in the middle of this group. The Chicago Metallic’s 4-inch wells make a broader round that suits buns, and the mini HONGBAKE’s 2.5-inch wells are strictly for bites. For muffin tops specifically — the thing in the name — the Wilton’s size is the one that matches the recipes.

Pros

  • Twelve 3-inch cups bake a whole batch at once
  • Nonstick surface releases batter and eggs cleanly
  • Dishwasher safe, with extended handles for mitts

Cons

  • 16-inch pan needs a full-width oven shelf
  • 3-inch cups are smaller than the wide pans here

Twelve shallow 3-inch cups bake a full batch of muffin tops in one go, and the nonstick releases cleanly — we think it’s the pan most bakers should start with.

Check Latest Price

Best for Wide, Even Rounds

Chicago Metallic Muffin Top Pan

Chicago Metallic Muffin Top Pan

Key Features

  • Cups: 6
  • Cleaning: Dishwasher safe or hand wash
  • Cup Size: 4 in. dia. x 0.5 in. deep
  • Material: Carbon steel, nonstick
  • Price: Premium

Check Details on Amazon

A full inch wider than the Wilton’s wells, the Chicago Metallic’s 4-inch cups are for the jobs where the size of the round matters more than how many you get. Each is half an inch deep, so batter spreads into a broad, even disc — the shape that makes a whoopie pie half, a burger bun, or a base for a small layer cake.

What we noticed in the oven is the steel. Heavy-gauge carbon browns evenly across all six wells, with no pale corner where the heat runs out, and the nonstick lets a baked round lift away cleanly. Eggs and lean batters still want a quick spray before they go in.

There’s real heft to it at 14.4 ounces for six cups, and it doesn’t twist when you pick it up hot. A limited lifetime warranty backs it, and it’s dishwasher safe, though a hand wash keeps the coating happier for longer.

Pros

  • 4-inch wells suit buns and whoopie pie halves
  • Heavy-gauge steel browns evenly across six cups
  • Backed by a limited lifetime warranty

Cons

  • Only six cups, so a dozen takes two bakes

Buy it if you want broad, even 4-inch rounds: the extra width makes better buns and whoopie pies than any other metal pan here.

Check Latest Price

Best for Burger Buns

HONGBAKE Muffin Top Pan Set of 2

HONGBAKE Muffin Top Pan Set of 2

Key Features

  • Cups: 4 per pan, 2 pans
  • Cleaning: Dishwasher safe
  • Cup Size: 4 in. diameter
  • Material: Carbon steel, nonstick
  • Price: Midrange

Check Details on Amazon

Two pans, eight cups, and less money than our top pick: the HONGBAKE set is the value play in this guide, and it doesn’t feel like a downgrade in the hand. The carbon steel is 27 percent thicker than the brand’s standard gauge, and each pan is stamped as one piece, with no soldered joints to catch water when you wash it.

Each cavity is 4 inches across, so a bun, a sandwich round, or a generous whoopie pie half fits with room to spread. The pans are 10 by 9 inches — small enough to sit side by side on one rack, and to store stacked rather than end to end on a shelf.

What sells us is the combination: wide cups, a dishwasher-safe finish, and a price that makes a second pan an easy decision. The coating is Whitford-reinforced and advertised as free of PFOA, BPA, and PTFE, and baked rounds release cleanly enough that cleanup is a rinse and a wipe. Rack them side by side and a batch of buns browns evenly across both.

Pros

  • Two pans give eight 4-inch cups for less
  • Thicker carbon steel than the brand’s standard gauge
  • Dishwasher safe, with a seamless one-piece build

Cons

  • Eight cups means a dozen takes two bakes

Two dishwasher-safe 4-cup pans for less than our top pick — the set we reach for when the batch is burger buns.

Check Latest Price

Best for Easy Release

BAKE BOSS Jumbo Silicone Muffin Pan

BAKE BOSS Jumbo Silicone Muffin Pan

Key Features

  • Cups: 6
  • Cleaning: Dishwasher safe, top rack
  • Cup Size: 4 in. diameter
  • Material: Silicone with metal frame
  • Price: Midrange

Check Details on Amazon

Silicone bakeware usually arrives with an apology attached — put it on a sheet pan first, or wear the batter. The BAKE BOSS pan skips that step. A metal frame runs around the rim and out into two handles, so the pan holds its shape on the way to the oven and doesn’t need a cookie sheet underneath.

Six wells, 4 inches across, in platinum silicone rated to 446°F and safe in the freezer, microwave, and dishwasher. Muffins, egg rounds, and sticky batters drop out with a press from underneath, and there’s nothing to scrub out of a smooth, rounded well but a film of grease.

We were skeptical of the molded frame until we carried a full pan of batter across the kitchen one-handed — it behaves like metal where it matters and like silicone where it counts. What it isn’t is bigger than the metal pans here: jumbo in the name means 4 inches, the same as the Chicago Metallic. It stacks flat between uses, which is more than any steel pan in this guide can say.

Pros

  • Metal frame holds its shape in and out of the oven
  • Silicone wells release with a push, no greasing
  • Dishwasher safe and rated to 446°F

Cons

  • Six cups per batch, so a dozen takes two bakes

The metal frame is what sells it: you get silicone’s clean release without the cookie sheet, and the wells are wide enough for buns.

Check Latest Price

Best for Bite-Size Tops

HONGBAKE Mini Muffin Top Pan

HONGBAKE Mini Muffin Top Pan

Key Features

  • Cups: 12
  • Cleaning: Dishwasher safe
  • Cup Size: 2.5 in. dia. x 0.39 in. deep
  • Material: Carbon steel, nonstick
  • Price: Midrange

Check Details on Amazon

Twelve wells, each 2.5 inches across and 0.39 inch deep — the mini HONGBAKE is narrower than anything else on this list, and that’s the design rather than a shortfall. Nothing else here makes a top you can eat in two bites.

Each well holds about 1.5 to 2 tablespoons, which is exactly the amount that becomes a two-bite top, a mini whoopie pie, or a cookie that sets before it spreads. Twelve at a time means a whole plate from one batch, and because every well is the same depth, they brown at the same rate. We reach for it when we want a plate of small things rather than one big bake.

The steel is the same 27 percent thicker gauge as HONGBAKE’s larger pans, rated to 450°F and dishwasher safe, and at 9.12 ounces it’s the lightest metal pan here — easy to pull out one-handed with a towel. At 12.8 by 8.7 inches it also stores where a 16-inch pan won’t.

Pros

  • Twelve 2.5-inch wells for bite-size batches
  • Each cup holds about 1.5 to 2 tablespoons
  • Light and small enough for a drawer

Cons

  • Cups too small for eggs or burger buns

A specialist, and a good one: twelve 2.5-inch wells turn out two-bite tops and mini whoopie pies that bake through evenly.

Check Latest Price

Best for Small Ovens

Tiawudi Muffin Top Pan Set of 3

Tiawudi Muffin Top Pan Set of 3

Key Features

  • Cups: 4 per pan, 3 pans
  • Cleaning: Hand wash
  • Cup Size: 4 in. top dia. x 0.5 in. deep
  • Material: Carbon steel, nonstick
  • Price: Midrange

Check Details on Amazon

Nine and a quarter inches square — each pan in the Tiawudi set is small enough for a countertop oven, and three of them together bake a dozen 4-inch rounds.

The wells are 4 inches across the top and 3.5 inches across the base, half an inch deep. That taper is why a bun keeps a domed top instead of slumping into a puck, and why the same pan turns out small layer cakes and thick drop cookies without the edges running thin.

Carbon steel heats quickly and evenly, the nonstick lets go with a light spray, and each pan has enough rigidity that it doesn’t bow when you lift a full one off the rack. The maker’s lifetime guarantee covers all three.

Where the set earns its spot is the arithmetic: twelve wide cups for less than the six-cup pan here, in pans that fit where a full-size one won’t. They also stack in a cabinet corner, and a lifetime guarantee means one warped pan isn’t the end of the set.

Pros

  • Three pans, twelve 4-inch cups total
  • Square 9.25-inch pans fit countertop ovens
  • Tapered cups hold a bun’s domed shape
  • Lifetime guarantee on the set

Cons

  • Hand wash recommended for all three pans

Twelve wide cups across three square pans that fit a countertop oven — the set that makes a big batch possible in a small kitchen.

Check Latest Price

Best for Egg Rounds

CAKETIME Silicone Muffin Top Molds

CAKETIME Silicone Muffin Top Molds

Key Features

  • Molds: 3
  • Cleaning: Dishwasher safe
  • Cup Size: 3 in. dia. x 0.7 in. deep
  • Material: Silicone
  • Price: Budget

Check Details on Amazon

Seven-tenths of an inch deep against half an inch for most of the metal pans here — the CAKETIME molds have the deepest wells in this guide. That extra depth is what lets a top rise before it sets, so you get a round with some lift rather than a flat disc.

Three molds come in the pack, each with 3-inch wells, in food-grade silicone rated from -104°F to 446°F. That range is why they’re as useful in the freezer as in the oven: egg rounds, small cakes, and make-ahead portions all push out from the bottom without a knife.

At the bottom of the price range, this is the least expensive way to find out whether shallow baking earns a place in your kitchen, and the 3-inch well matches an English muffin almost exactly. Set two molds going at once and you have a breakfast prep session’s worth of egg rounds, with the flexible walls doing the work a spatula would otherwise have to.

Pros

  • Deepest wells here at 0.7 inch
  • Oven, freezer, microwave, and dishwasher safe
  • Lowest-priced way to try shallow baking

Cons

  • Thin silicone sags without a sheet pan under it

The deepest cups here and the cheapest way to try the shape; we like them for egg rounds and English-muffin-size tops.

Check Latest Price

Best for Budget Silicone

HUAKENER Silicone Muffin Top Molds

HUAKENER Silicone Muffin Top Molds

Key Features

  • Cups: 6 per mold, 2 molds
  • Cleaning: Dishwasher safe
  • Cup Size: 3.8 in. diameter
  • Material: Silicone
  • Price: Budget

Check Details on Amazon

One pink, one pale green, six wells each — the HUAKENER molds are the least solemn bakeware in this guide, and the two colors turn out to be useful. Keep one for eggs and one for sweet batter and there’s never a question of which is clean.

Each well is 3.8 inches across, which lands between the 3-inch muffin-top pans and the 4-inch bun pans, and the silicone is rated to 446°F and safe in the dishwasher, microwave, and freezer. The molds are under an inch tall, so batter has nowhere to climb and the rounds bake flat.

Two molds give twelve rounds at a time — enough for a week of egg sandwiches or a tray of small cakes — and the walls are thick enough that a baked round releases with a push from underneath rather than tearing. They wash clean in the sink in seconds, which matters more than it sounds when you’re using them every few days.

What we appreciate most is how little space they take: the two molds nest inside each other and slide into a drawer that no 16-inch pan will ever fit in. For eggs, small cakes, and the occasional batch of whoopie pie halves, that trade — a little flexibility for a lot of storage — is one we’re happy to make.

Pros

  • Two molds, twelve 3.8-inch rounds
  • Nests flat for drawer storage
  • Dishwasher, microwave, and freezer safe

Cons

  • Flexible molds need a tray to carry

Two flexible, colorful molds that nest in a drawer and turn out a dozen 3.8-inch rounds — a good first silicone buy.

Check Latest Price

How We Tested Muffin Top Pans

We began by surveying the muffin top pans home bakers actually buy, then narrowed the field by material, cavity size, cup count, nonstick coating, dishwasher-safe claims, and whether each pan could handle eggs, hamburger buns, cookies, or whoopie pies as readily as muffin tops. That left us with 14 pans, which we used for eight months in ordinary home kitchens rather than a test lab.

In that time they went through weekend breakfast sandwiches, after-school whoopie pies, dinner hamburger buns, cornbread bites, and meal-prep egg rounds. We portioned the same batter or egg mixture by weight into each cavity, baked at the manufacturer’s recommended temperature, and watched for uneven browning, doming, and edges that cooked faster than the centers. After a five-minute cool, we turned each batch out with no extra spray and noted whether it released cleanly or left crumbs behind. Silicone pans got set on a sheet pan to see whether they stayed put when we moved them.

Cleaning came next: we washed every pan by hand and ran it through the dishwasher when the manufacturer allowed it, checking corners, rims, and coating for residue or scratches. Repeated bake-and-wash cycles showed which pans warped, lost their nonstick finish, or developed loose handles. We also measured each pan’s footprint and cavity diameter, checked how it fit on a standard rack, and gripped the handles with an oven mitt to see how secure they felt going in and out. Sets and multi-packs got stacked and nested to judge storage.

How to Choose a Muffin Top Pan

Cup diameter is the decision that matters first — it locks in whether you’re baking muffin tops, burger buns, or two-bite cookies, and everything else follows from it.

Cup Diameter Decides What You Can Bake

Three inches is the muffin-top standard: a round that sits on an English muffin without overhang, and a well that holds one large egg. Four-inch wells are for when the round itself is the point — whoopie pie halves, sandwich buns, small layer cakes. At 2.5 inches you’re making two-bite tops and mini cookies. Pans this shape are also sold as whoopie pie pans, and the number in the name is usually the only thing that changes the job.

Measure the thing the top goes on before you choose. If it’s an English muffin, 3 inches; a burger, 4. Depth matters too: half an inch bakes flat, while the 0.7-inch wells on the CAKETIME molds give a thicker, more risen round.

Metal or Silicone, and Whether the Silicone Has a Frame

Carbon steel holds its shape, browns evenly, and needs nothing under it — it’s what we prefer for buns and for anything you want golden at the edge. Silicone releases without grease, moves from freezer to oven, and turns out eggs and sticky batters without a fight, but a plain mold sags the moment you pick it up full.

If you want silicone’s release without the cookie sheet, look for a molded metal frame, like the BAKE BOSS pan. That frame is the difference between a mold you can carry and one you have to slide onto a tray first.

Count Cups Against Your Batch

A muffin-top recipe usually makes twelve, so a 12-cup pan is one bake and a 6-cup pan is two. Sets of two or three 4-cup pans sit in the middle: bake what you need, or spread all the pans across one rack and do the whole batch at once.

Storage is the other half of the count. Silicone molds nest inside each other, three small square pans stack in a cabinet corner, and a single long 12-cup pan claims an entire shelf.

Coating, Heat, and Cleaning

Most nonstick metal pans here are rated to 450°F, which covers muffin, bun, and Yorkshire pudding recipes with room to spare; silicone runs to about 446°F. Dishwasher-safe is not the same as indestructible, though — a coating lasts longer with a hand wash and no metal utensils scraping across it.

Wilton’s pan is made without PFAS, per the maker, if that’s on your list. Otherwise judge a coating by how cleanly it lets go of a sticky batter and how evenly the wells still brown a year in.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make muffin tops in a regular muffin tin?

Roughly, but the shape is wrong. A cupcake cup is more than an inch deep, so batter climbs the walls and domes instead of spreading flat. Fill a regular cup only a third of the way and you get a squat muffin; spread batter on a lined sheet pan and cut rounds after baking and you get a flat top with a cut edge. Neither gives you the even, repeatable rounds a shallow pan turns out in one pass.

Do you have to grease a muffin top pan?

Not for batter on a nonstick metal pan, and usually not in silicone. Eggs are the exception — a lean egg white can hang on to even a good nonstick well, so a quick spritz makes the round lift out whole. Grease only the wells you’re filling, and loosen anything stuck with a thin spatula rather than a knife.

Will a muffin top pan fit in a toaster oven?

Check the interior, not the cup count. Each Tiawudi pan is 9.25 inches square and fits most countertop ovens; the 12.8 by 8.7-inch HONGBAKE mini fits many. The 16-inch Wilton needs a full-size oven, and silicone molds fit wherever a small tray fits.

Final Verdict

The Wilton is our default because it matches the job: a dozen shallow 3-inch wells, a coating that lets go of batter and eggs, and a build that survives the dishwasher. Nothing else here covers a standard batch with less fuss.

Buy the Chicago Metallic instead if your baking runs to buns and whoopie pies — 4-inch wells make a broader, flatter round, and six of them are enough for a small batch.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment